709 deaths, 8,521 release obstacle, countless violations

  • actual
  • 11:27 26 December 2024
  • |
img

ISTANBUL - Prisoners living in “isolation within isolation” were subjected to countless violations throughout the year. At least 709 prisoners lost their lives, 8,521 people were prevented from being released and solidarity with prisoners was criminalized. 

Prisons are one of the areas that have been on the agenda with rights violations from past to present. Torture and ill-treatment, unhealthy living conditions, nutrition, housing, disciplinary punishments and severe isolation are just some of the violations in prisons. Many prisoners and political prisoners lost their lives during the year due to these violations.  
 
According to the data of the General Directorate of Prisons and Detention Houses of the Ministry of Justice dated December 1, 2024; there are 406 prisons in Turkey and Kurdistan, 273 of which are closed prisons. The capacity of these prisons is 299,42. 
 
“The number of penal execution institutions and detention centers should be rapidly reduced in line with reducing operating costs, quality in service and modern execution understanding,” the Directorate's data reads. However, the government's practices contradict the “target” on the directorate's website. 
 
Minister of Justice Yılmaz Tunç announced in Parliament in November that 11 prisons were under construction and 21 prison projects were being studied for 2025. On the other hand, 378,657 people are currently staying in prisons with a capacity of 299,42 people. 
 
709 DEATHS IN 11 MONTHS 
 
Throughout 2024, there has been no shortage of news of deaths in prisons. Many prisoners and political prisoners, whose release was prevented due to the “can stay in prison” reports issued by the Forensic Medicine Institution (ATK), lost their lives. According to the Human Rights Association (IHD), at least 50 prisoners lost their lives in the first 9 months of 2024. Most of those who lost their lives were ill prisoners. 
 
The Ministry of Justice also announced new data during the budget talks in Parliament. The Ministry of Justice announced that 709 detainees and political prisoners lost their lives in prisons in the 11 months of 2024.  
 
Abdulkadir Kuday was one of the ill prisoners left to die in prison. Kuday, who suffered from ALS and was prevented from being released despite his severe health problems, died in Metris Type R Closed Prison on October 2. 
 
Another ill prisoner, Mehmet Ali Bakış (68), had been receiving cancer treatment in Erzurum Oltu T Type Closed Prison for many years. Unable to withstand the heavy prison conditions, Varışlı was taken to Van Yüzüncü Yıl University Faculty of Medicine due to internal bleeding and died on January 17.
 
Some of the people who lost their lives during the year were as follows: Recep Koçak (68), İsmet Çardak, Mutlak Tozun (52), Ergün Akdoğan (58), Ercan Çakar (39), Yıldırım Han, Mehmet Ali Yaşa, Cengiz Dal, Ümit Kayaboynu, Abdülmelik Okyay (71), İbrahim Boğurcu (32), Serhat Temizer (21), Salih Kayra, Adem Cirit (88), Mizgin Acar, Adnan Karayiğit and Cemal Altıparkmakoğlu.
 
8,521 DETAINEES PREVENTED FROM RELEASE
 
The Administrative and Prison Monitoring Boards, which came into force in 2021, delayed the release of many prisoners throughout the year. It is not known how many prisoners the boards have prevented from being released since their establishment. The Ministry of Justice released a statement on this in October. According to the ministry, the release of 8,521 people was delayed on the grounds of “lack of good behavior”. 
 
Human rights organizations and lawyers say that these committees put themselves in the place of the judiciary. The reason for this is the questions the boards ask when assessing “good behavior” and the allegations they make as justification for delaying releases. Many prisoners' releases were extended on grounds such as “overusing electricity and water”, “not appearing before the board”, “not showing remorse”, “not taking books from the library” and “beating the door”. Some prisoners were extended for 3 years, some for 6 years and some for 1 year each. 
 
The practices against prisoners were not limited to this. Dozens of prisoners (many of them 30 years old) were burned to death during the year.  
 
ILL PRISONERS
 
Ill prisoners are the most affected by the violations in prisons. The Ministry does not share any data on sick prisoners. According to the data of the Civil Society in the Penal Execution System (CISST), there are 19 people with speech and language disabilities, 42 people with visual disabilities, 28 people with hearing disabilities, 18 people with hearing and speech disabilities and 162 people with orthopaedic disabilities, i.e. 269 disabled prisoners in total.
 
According to the outdated data of the Human Rights Association (IHD), there are more than a thousand ill prisoners in prisons.
 
There are 5,520 prisoners over the age of 65. Some of these are political prisoners. Hatice Yıldız, 75 years old, who was sentenced to 4 years and 2 months in prison on the allegation of "financing an illegal organisation" for sending money to her daughter and her daughter's ward mate in prison, is just one of these prisoners. Hatice Yıldız has been held in Bakırköy Women's Closed Prison since 23 March.
 
SOLIDARITY CAMPAIGN WITH PRISONERS
 
Another prominent issue regarding prisons during the year was that money sent to prisoners was investigated as "financing an illegal organization". Many people, including Hatice Onaran, one of the executives of IHD, were arrested for sending money to prisoners in prisons. This was also used as a pretext for many investigations and lawsuits. IHD and the Association of Families of Prisoners and Prisoners' Families (TUHAYDER), stating that sending money to prisons cannot be considered a criminal offence, started a campaign of "depositing money to prisoners". In this context, money is sent to prisoners every week in many cities.
 
ISOLATION WITHIN ISOLATION
 
The policy of isolation was deepened throughout the year. Prisoners were subjected to "isolation within isolation" in the Y, S and High Security prisons that have been built in recent years. According to the data of the Ministry of Justice, there are 7 S and 14 type Y prisons. In these prisons, prisoners are completely prevented from contact with the outside and people. Even small windows are covered with wire fences, preventing the sun from entering. While the cells are monitored by cameras 24 hours a day, prisoners' ventilation hours are limited to 1 hour a day.
 
The Prisoners' Solidarity Initiative (TDI) launched a campaign at the beginning of 2024 to close these prisons, which deepen the isolation. Within the framework of the campaign, meetings with prisoners' families and statements were made in front of prisons and courthouses. In addition, various actions and events were organised to raise awareness against the isolation in prisons.
 
Tomorrow: Judiciary
 
MA / Ömer İbrahimoğlu 

View More Articles

23/01/2025
10:26 International conventions the law of war are ignored in Tishreen says Journalist Cihan
09:49 Isolation must be lifted, negotiations must be opened says İHD member Güldane Kılıç
22/01/2025
13:53 Syrian Foreign Minister Sheibani calls on Kurds
13:43 144 violations detected in İmralı
12:33 Young man run over by an armoured vehicle: I was beaten, the doctor did not examine me
11:49 Letter he wrote about violations considered as 'disrupt the unity and territorial integrity of the state'
11:21 Journalist Eylem Babayiğit detained
10:59 DEM Party delegation in İmralı
10:35 Palestinian woman reunited with her 'hostage' baby
10:34 What do relatives of the disappeared say about the Kurdish issue?
10:21 Attacks violating right to life must be stopped says Lawyer
10:08 They must sit at table and talk about solution say Prisoners' relatives
10:01 Raphaëlle Primet: Öcalan is indispensable for the solution of the Kurdish issue
09:52 New government conundrum in Federated Kurdistan
09:20 240 detentions in 2 weeks
08:59 DEM Party Delegation will go to İmralı
21/01/2025
16:50 Freedom Watch in Strasbourg in its 657th week
16:44 Tens of thousands honour those massacred in Tishreen
16:34 Rojhilat prisoners call for participation in general strike
16:33 2024 balance sheet of SDF in fight against ISIS
15:12 Turkey attacks olive factory
14:50 Message from Bavê Teyar's prisoner daughter
14:21 Attack on Tishreen: Wounded
14:21 Call to increase struggle at trustee protest in Akdeniz
12:07 Lawyers applies to meet with Abdullah Öcalan
12:06 Abdullah Öcalan letter from intellectuals to Council of Europe
11:18 Same judge arrested 13 journalists in a month
11:04 Decision was pre-determined says arrested journalists lawyer
10:30 Prisoner who objected to handcuffing not treated
09:43 'There will be no peace until Abdullah Öcalan is free'
20/01/2025
16:23 6 journalists arrested
16:16 Attacks on Tishreen condemned in 3 centers
15:05 Trustee protest in Akdeniz on its 11th day
15:04 Protest for Pakshan Azizi in front of Iranian Embassy
14:47 Turkey bombed water reservoir
14:46 'Peace' meeting of women: Our struggle for a free life
13:38 Reaction from 12 bar associations on attacks against Tishreen
12:30 Prosecutor referred journalists for arrest without taking testify
12:17 General strike against executions in Rojhilat
12:02 İmralı Delegation apply to Ministry of Justice
11:51 It's state's turn to take steps, CHP must be part of process says Tülay Hatimoğulları
11:26 Detained journalists appear in court
10:41 People react against Tishreen attacks
10:08 6 prisoners sentenced for cutting wires
09:52 Justice Commission for Rojin Kabaiş: We will follow the case
09:17 'Shoe search' imposition to women prisoners
19/01/2025
12:40 Jin magazine focuses on women's resistance against labour exploitation
10:32 Solution through dialogue will be benefical for everyone says Salih Muslim
10:32 İmralı Delegation apply to Ministry of Justice tomorrow
18/01/2025
17:42 Call from Şirnex: Stop the attacks in Tishreen