Constitutional Court rules seizure of letters a violation: No place in a democratic society

img

ANKARA – The Constitutional Court ruled that the “objectionable” seizure of letters sent by 11 prisoners in prisons was not necessary in a “democratic society”. 

The Constitutional Court of Turkey ruled on the application made by 11 prisoners in different prisons regarding the confiscation of letters sent by prisoners in prisons by disciplinary committees. 
Prisoners Kamil Özdemir, Aydın Çiçin, Hasan Didar, Hasan Umut Özer, İsa Kaya, Mehmet Karaman, Muhammed Salih Gürakar, Mümin Evran, Nurettin Bülbül, Selman Esmer and Serkan Cengiz appealed to the Execution Judgeships in their cities after their letters were seized by disciplinary boards.
 
When the Execution Judges rejected the appeals the prisoners took the matter to the High Criminal Court. The Court rejected the appeals and upheld the decisions without providing a concrete justification for the content of the letters. In response, 11 prisoners filed an individual application to the Constitutional Court, claiming that they were not provided with sufficient justification and that their freedom of communication was violated. 
 
LETTER TO JOURNALIST REACHED AFTER 4 YEARS
 
Some of the letters blocked by the Disciplinary Board as "objectionable" were addressed to family and friends, while others were addressed to politicians, journalists or public figures. The letters contained observations on daily life and statements about the practices in prisons. A letter that Hasan Umut Özer, a prisoner in Sincan High Security Prison No 1, wanted to send to journalist and writer Hüseyin Aykol during his stay in Karabük T-Type Prison in 2018 was delivered to Aykol after an interval of 4 years.
The Constitutional Court merged the applications filed at different times due to the legal connection in terms of subject matter.
 
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT: OBJECTIONABLE PARTS MAY BE UNDERLINED
 
Evaluation the application within the scope of the freedom of communication guaranteed under Article 22 of the Constitution, the court stated that the inspection and detention of prisoners’ letters constituted and interference with the freedom of communication. On the other hand, the Constitutional Court found that the decisions of the disciplinary board and the judicial authorities did not provide concrete and coherent justifications for the content of the letters, did not clearly state which expressions were objectionable and why, and did not evaluate the possibility of sending the letters by crossing out the objectionable parts. 
 
'NOT NECESSARY IN A DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY'
 
On the other hand, the Constitutional Court underlined that if the correspondence is deemed partially objectionable, it should also be evaluated whether the objectionable parts should be crossed out and the correspondence should be delivered to the addressee and emphasised that “the intervention is not necessary in a democratic society”. 
 
For all these reasons, the Court ruled that the freedom of communication of 11 prisoners was violated. 
 

View More Articles

14:47 ‘Truth Commission on Conflict and Children’ to be established
13:56 Turkey once again excludes öcalan from the "right to hope"
12:36 ISIG: 164 workers lost their lives in June
12:13 Nightlong vigil against mine in Hesendin
12:10 Release decision for journalist Ucar
11:31 Governorate declares ban to 3 regions of Elkê
11:12 Women in Ankara for 'Peace March'
11:05 İmralı Delegation and Ministry of Justice meeting postpone
10:26 Public meetings: Full trust in Öcalan, demand for equal citizenship
09:42 Alevis will convey their demands to commission to be established
09:19 If we listen to Öcalan, we can reach a solution
07/07/2025
23:33 KCK: Ceremony will proceed as planned, but it will not be broadcast live
19:45 Imrali Delegation to meet Minister of Justice
19:34 Family meeting in İmralı
16:53 İmralı Delegation: Reciprocal will to move process forward continues
16:13 Erdogan-İmralı delegation meeting end
16:00 Call of Abdullah Öcalan expected for the ceremony says Journalist Aslan
15:31 Erdogan-İmralı Delegation meeting start
15:26 Kurdish struggle inspiring says Miloon Kothari
06/07/2025
20:16 Abdullah Öcalan: We are entering a new phase
17:03 MKG: 7 women journalists detained, 2 arrested
15:34 DEM Party İmralı Delegation to meet President Erdogan tomorrow
15:04 DEM Party İmralı delegation meeting with Abdullah Öcalan end
14:02 Fire extinguished on Gabar Mountain
13:53 Young people met at the workshop: We will lead the construction of a democratic society
13:16 Committee to 'seize' Kurdish property in Afrin!
12:49 Untreated prisoner loses eye
12:09 I want to meet and discuss with Öcalan says Djemila Benhabib
11:54 JINNEWS June tally: 19 women and 1 child murdered
11:42 DEM Party delegation go to İmralı
10:24 Status demand to Kurdish language: We can play active rol in process
09:32 World’s eyes on PKK: Which parties and organisations to follow?
04/07/2025
16:17 ‘Öcalan's plan has the potential to stabilize the Middle East’
16:05 Forest Fire in Omerya Area
15:57 Fire in Gabar spreads over a wide area
13:24 Arrest warrant request for Tunc Soyer and 98 Others
12:05 137 people reffered to Court in İzmir
11:50 Families apply to İmralı Directorate
11:43 Visitation ban imposed on prisoners in Wan
10:50 IHRNGO Director: Aim of the repression is to prevent new protests
09:57 Youth to meet on agenda of ‘Peace and Democratic Society Process’
09:55 We are more hopeful than ever for national unity says KNK Co-chair
09:25 'There is no chance to postpone or delay the national congress'
09:24 'I want to visit Öcalan' campaign: The main goal is freedom of Öcalan
03/07/2025
16:34 What did the European delegation discuss at the 'Round Table'?
14:05 DEM Party convenes
14:04 DFG June report: 16 detentions, 6 arrests
12:34 Youth to organize 'Democratic Society Workshop'
11:04 Legal regulations are needed to make process permanent says CHP member
11:03 IHD Istanbul Branch Chair: Ill prisoners cannot wait for September-October